Movie of the Day: Psycho Therapy: The Shallow Tale of a Writer Who Decided to Write About a Serial Killer (2024) by Tolga Karaçelik
- dailyentertainment95
- Apr 23
- 8 min read
Link to watch: https://www.justwatch.com/us/movie/psycho-therapy-the-shallow-tale-of-a-writer-who-decided-to-write-about-a-serial-killer (US), https://www.justwatch.com/ca/movie/psycho-therapy-the-shallow-tale-of-a-writer-who-decided-to-write-about-a-serial-killer (Canada)
Link IMDB: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt17492148/
"Psycho Therapy: The Shallow Tale of a Writer Who Decided to Write About a Serial Killer (2024)" by Tolga Karaçelik: A Darkly Comic Dive into Creativity and Connection
"Psycho Therapy: The Shallow Tale of a Writer Who Decided to Write About a Serial Killer," a 2024 dark comedy-drama from Turkish director Tolga Karaçelik in his English-language debut, presents an unconventional and often absurd look at the intersection of creative desperation, marital woes, and an unlikely friendship. The film centers on a struggling writer who finds an unexpected muse and confidante in a retired serial killer.
Detailed Summary
The film introduces Keane (John Magaro), a writer facing both a creative block and the impending dissolution of his marriage to Suzie (Britt Lower). Desperate for inspiration for his next book and perhaps some form of guidance in his chaotic personal life, Keane unexpectedly crosses paths with Kollmick (Steve Buscemi), a seemingly mild-mannered individual who reveals himself to be a retired serial killer. In a bizarre and darkly humorous turn of events, Kollmick agrees to act as a consultant for Keane's writing, offering insights into the mind and methods of a killer. Their unconventional relationship deepens, and Kollmick finds himself dispensing advice not only on murder but also, inadvertently, on Keane's marital problems. The film explores the strange dynamic between the three characters, the blurred lines between inspiration and morbid fascination, and the lengths to which people will go for creative success and personal connection, all filtered through a lens of dark comedy and psychological absurdity against the backdrop of New York City.
Plot Summary
A struggling writer on the verge of divorce befriends a retired serial killer. The killer becomes the writer's muse for his new book and an unconventional advisor on his failing marriage, leading to darkly comedic and surreal situations.
Director's Vision
Tolga Karaçelik's vision for "Psycho Therapy" was to craft a dark comedy that is both sincere and unsettling, pushing audiences outside their comfort zone. As his English-language debut, he aimed for a distinct visual style, describing it as "Gotham-y," eerie, and somewhat pop-ish, reflecting the film's blend of grim themes and dark humor. Karaçelik emphasized the importance of maintaining a sincere and consistent rhythm in the characters and scenes, allowing for authentic interactions even within the absurd premise. He was drawn to the idea of exploring the creative process and the unconventional connections that can form between people, using the darkly comedic scenario to delve into themes of marital issues and the search for meaning and inspiration. The fast-paced nature of the 22-day shoot in New York City also played a role in shaping the film's energy and aesthetic.
Themes
The Creative Process and Desperation: The film explores the lengths to which a writer will go for inspiration and the often-unconventional sources it can come from.
Marital Dysfunction and Communication: The failing marriage of the protagonist serves as a significant plot point and a source of both drama and dark comedy.
Unconventional Connections: The bizarre friendship between the writer and the retired serial killer highlights the unexpected bonds that can form between individuals.
Blurred Lines Between Fascination and Morality: The film delves into the ethical questions raised by the writer's willingness to engage with a serial killer for his work.
Identity and Performance: The characters, particularly Kollmick, present different facades, raising questions about their true identities and motivations.
Dark Humor and Absurdity: The film utilizes dark comedy to explore uncomfortable themes and situations, creating a sense of absurdity.
Key Success Factors
Based on its reception and reviews, key success factors for "Psycho Therapy" include:
Intriguing and Absurd Premise: The high-concept idea of a writer seeking inspiration from a serial killer is inherently captivating and lends itself to dark comedy.
Strong Lead Cast: The involvement of acclaimed actors like Steve Buscemi, John Magaro, and Britt Lower has drawn significant attention and their performances are often praised.
Distinct Darkly Comic Tone: The film's successful navigation of dark humor blended with dramatic elements is a key factor for viewers who appreciate this style.
Film Festival Recognition: Its premiere at the Tribeca Festival and recognition as a runner-up for the Audience Award indicate its ability to connect with festival audiences.
Summary Short
"Psycho Therapy: The Shallow Tale of a Writer Who Decided to Write About a Serial Killer (2024)" by Tolga Karaçelik is a dark comedy where a struggling writer in a failing marriage befriends a retired serial killer who becomes his unconventional muse and counselor.
Awards and Nominations
"Psycho Therapy: The Shallow Tale of a Writer Who Decided to Write About a Serial Killer (2024)" was recognized at the 2024 Tribeca Festival as a runner-up for the Audience Award in the Narrative competition. Specific details about other awards or nominations are not widely available in the initial search results.
Critics Reception
Critical reception for "Psycho Therapy: The Shallow Tale of a Writer Who Decided to Write About a Serial Killer" is mixed, according to available reviews.
Metacritic: Assigned a weighted average score of 55 out of 100 based on 6 critic reviews, indicating "mixed or average" reviews.
Original-Cin: Gave the film a perfect score (100), calling it a "charming return to form for the adult comedy—dialogue-driven, character-first, and delightfully absurd."
Collider: Offered a positive review, highlighting the engaging nature of the film and the captivating performances, stating that parting with the characters would be difficult.
Paste Magazine & Screen Rant: Provided more critical reviews, with some finding the screenplay derailing in the closing minutes, the ending abrupt, and the overall execution uneven despite strong performances. One review from Paste Magazine found the film lacking in energy and humor.
Eye For Film: Noted that while the characters and cast work well, the film lacks energy and the ending lacks conviction, but found it worthwhile for fans of the cast.
Jared Mobarak (Review): Found the absurdity entertaining and praised the lead actors' performances, noting that the film gets better in the third act despite some monotonous moments earlier.
Overall Summary of Critics Reception: Critics are divided on "Psycho Therapy." While many praise the performances of Steve Buscemi, John Magaro, and Britt Lower, and appreciate the film's unique premise and attempts at dark humor, opinions vary significantly on the execution, pacing, and the effectiveness of the script and ending. Some found it a fresh and engaging dark comedy, while others felt it didn't fully live up to its potential or was uneven in tone and narrative.
Reviews
Reviews for "Psycho Therapy" present a range of perspectives. Those who enjoyed the film highlighted its successful blend of dark comedy and drama, the strong chemistry and performances of the lead cast, and the intriguing nature of the premise. More critical reviews often pointed to issues with pacing, an abrupt or unsatisfying ending, and an unevenness in the script's ability to maintain its tone and effectively explore its themes. The film appears to be one that resonates strongly with some viewers and critics while leaving others less impressed.
Production
"Psycho Therapy: The Shallow Tale of a Writer Who Decided to Write About a Serial Killer (2024)" is a co-production between the United States and Turkey, marking Tolga Karaçelik's English-language debut. The film was produced by several companies including Curious Gremlin, Olive Productions, Cinegryphon Entertainment, and May Productions, among others. Notably, lead actors Steve Buscemi, John Magaro, and Britt Lower also have producing roles. Principal photography took place in New York City over a concise 22-day shoot in the summer of 2023.
Production Companies
Curious Gremlin: (Country: United States) - Production company.
Olive Productions: (Country: United States) - Production company.
Cinegryphon Entertainment: (Country: United States) - Production company.
May Productions: (Country: United States) - Production company.
Asteros Film: (Country: Not specified) - Production company.
Theatriste: (Country: Not specified) - Production company.
Pak Pictures: (Country: Not specified) - Production company.
Mavi Baykus: (Country: Turkey) - Production company.
Sales Companies
CAA Media Finance
Distribution Companies
Brainstorm Media: (Country: United States) - Distributed the film theatrically and on digital platforms in the United States.
Release Date on Streaming
"Psycho Therapy: The Shallow Tale of a Writer Who Decided to Write About a Serial Killer (2024)" was released on digital and VOD platforms on April 11, 2025.
Theatrical Release
The film had its World Premiere at the 2024 Tribeca Festival on June 8, 2024. It received a limited theatrical release in the United States starting on April 4, 2025, distributed by Brainstorm Media. It also had a theatrical release in Turkey on April 18, 2025.
Why to Recommend This Movie
Unique and Bold Premise: The film's unconventional and darkly comedic concept is a major selling point for viewers looking for something different.
Strong Performances by a Talented Cast: Steve Buscemi, John Magaro, and Britt Lower deliver engaging and often praised performances.
Intriguing Blend of Genres: The film successfully combines elements of dark comedy, drama, and psychological themes.
Why to Watch Movie
For Fans of Dark Humor and Absurdity: If you appreciate films that find humor in uncomfortable and unusual situations, this movie is likely to appeal to you.
To See a Different Side of Acclaimed Actors: The film offers the lead cast members roles that allow them to explore unique and quirky characters.
Experience an English-Language Debut from a Promising Director: It's an opportunity to see how a director known for his work in another country approaches filmmaking in English.
What Movie Trend film is following
The film aligns with the trend of dark comedies that explore unconventional relationships and uncomfortable themes. It also fits within the trend of independent films featuring notable actors that premiere at festivals before limited theatrical and VOD releases. As an English-language debut by a foreign director, it also speaks to the increasing internationalization of filmmaking talent.
What Big Social Trend is following
The movie touches upon the social trend of the blurring lines between reality and mediated experiences, particularly in the context of seeking inspiration or connection. It also implicitly engages with conversations around mental health, therapy (albeit unconventional), and the complexities of modern relationships and divorce.
Final Verdict
"Psycho Therapy: The Shallow Tale of a Writer Who Decided to Write About a Serial Killer (2024)" is a bold and often engaging dark comedy that benefits significantly from its audacious premise and the strong performances of its lead cast. While its reception is mixed, indicating that its unique blend of humor and drama may not resonate with everyone, Tolga Karaçelik's English-language debut is a noteworthy effort. The film is at its best when leaning into the absurdity and the compelling dynamic between the struggling writer, his exasperated wife, and the surprisingly insightful serial killer. For viewers who appreciate unconventional storytelling, dark humor, and strong character work from a talented ensemble, "Psycho Therapy" offers a memorable, albeit potentially uneven, therapeutic session.
Recommendations for Filmmakers
Don't Be Afraid of Bold Concepts: An intriguing and unique premise can be a strong starting point, even if the execution is challenging.
Trust Your Actors: With a talented cast, allowing them the freedom to explore the characters and their dynamics can elevate the material, especially in character-driven stories.
Embrace a Distinct Tone: A clear and consistent tone, even in a dark comedy, helps guide the audience and can become a signature of your filmmaking style.
Recommendations for Movie Industry
Support Unique Voices and Premises: Continue to invest in and provide platforms for films with unconventional ideas and perspectives that push creative boundaries.
Recognize the Value of Festival Buzz: A strong reception at film festivals can be a key indicator of a film's potential to connect with audiences, even for independent or niche projects.
Facilitate Cross-Cultural Filmmaking: Encourage and support directors working outside their native countries and languages, as this can lead to fresh and interesting cinematic collaborations.
Commenti