New Movies: Profeti (2023) by Alessio Cremonini: Faith, Fear, and the Unseen Scars of War

The Core Story: A Journalist's Captivity and the Bonds Forged in Terror

"Profeti" (Prophets) is a 2023 Italian drama film directed by Alessio Cremonini, known for his gritty and realistic portrayals of contemporary issues, particularly in films like "On My Skin." The film delves into the harrowing experience of a Western war correspondent, Sara (Jasmine Trinca), who is held captive by ISIS in Syria.

The narrative centers on her intense and complex relationship with Nur (Isabelle Chihaoui), a young Syrian woman who, after escaping a similar captivity and enduring profound trauma, has converted to ISIS and now serves as Sara's jailer. As Sara endures the psychological and physical torment of her imprisonment, she grapples with the question of faith, the nature of radicalization, and the search for hope in the face of unimaginable despair. The film explores the unseen scars of war, the human capacity for both cruelty and empathy, and the desperate yearning for freedom and meaning, even when all seems lost. It’s a powerful two-hander that largely takes place within the confines of Sara's cell, magnifying the psychological tension and the intricate dynamic between captor and captive.

Short Summary: Captive and Convert

In Alessio Cremonini's "Profeti," a Western journalist, Sara (Jasmine Trinca), is held captive by ISIS in Syria. Her sole companion is Nur (Isabelle Chihaoui), a young Syrian convert who is now her jailer. The film intensely explores their complex, confined relationship, delving into themes of faith, radicalization, and the psychological scars of war as Sara desperately seeks meaning and freedom amidst her harrowing ordeal.

Link IMDB: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt14555712/

Link Review: https://cineuropa.org/en/newsdetail/437416/

About movie: https://truecolours.it/catalogue/prophets/

Link to watch: https://www.justwatch.com/it/film/profeti (Italy)

Detailed Look: Psychological Warfare in a Confined Space

"Profeti" distinguishes itself as a taut and emotionally charged psychological drama, primarily set within the stark confines of Sara's prison cell. Director Alessio Cremonini brings his signature realism and unflinching honesty to the subject matter, avoiding sensationalism to focus instead on the human cost of conflict and extremism. The film is essentially a two-hander, with the dynamic between Jasmine Trinca's Sara and Isabelle Chihaoui's Nur driving the narrative. Trinca delivers a powerful and physically demanding performance, conveying Sara's fear, resilience, and gradual understanding of her complex captor. Chihaoui, in turn, portrays Nur with a chilling mix of conviction, underlying trauma, and an eerie sense of self-righteousness, making her a compelling, multi-layered antagonist.

The film meticulously builds tension through dialogue and subtle shifts in power dynamics, rather than overt action. It delves into the psychological warfare waged by captors, but also the unexpected moments of shared humanity and understanding that can emerge even in the darkest circumstances. "Profeti" explores how radicalization can be a response to trauma and desperation, particularly for vulnerable individuals like Nur. The theme of "faith" is central, examined from both Sara's Western, often secular perspective, and Nur's fervent, radicalized devotion. The film has been praised for its brave and empathetic approach to a difficult subject, inviting audiences to reflect on the unseen forces that shape individuals in conflict zones. However, some critics note that while powerful, the film's intense focus on the confined space and dialogue might make it feel relentless at times.

Plot Summary: The Confined Conscience

• Capture and Confinement: Sara, a seasoned Western war correspondent, is captured by ISIS forces in Syria and confined to a stark, isolated cell.

• The Captor's Arrival: Her sole companion and jailer is Nur, a young Syrian woman who, having been previously captured and traumatized, has converted to radical Islam and now adheres strictly to ISIS ideology.

• A Battle of Wills and Beliefs: The film chronicles the intense psychological dynamic between Sara and Nur. Nur attempts to convert Sara to Islam and radicalize her, offering a perverse form of "salvation." Sara, while terrified, resists, engaging Nur in intellectual and emotional sparring, trying to understand her motivations and find a way to survive.

• Unseen Scars and Past Traumas: Through their conversations, the audience learns fragments of Nur's traumatic past (implied rape and displacement), which led to her radicalization. Sara's own journalistic drive and personal history also come to light.

• Fluctuating Power Dynamics: Their relationship shifts between moments of tension, subtle manipulation, unexpected empathy, and shared vulnerability, often driven by the brutal realities of their environment (e.g., sound of bombings, treatment of other prisoners).

• The Weight of Faith: The film delves deeply into the concept of faith – both radicalized and personal – and its role in survival, hope, and the justification of violence.

• The Quest for Freedom and Meaning: Sara's overarching goal is survival and escape, but the film also explores her search for meaning in her ordeal.

• Climax and Ambiguity: The narrative builds to a climax that tests both women's resolve and leaves the audience to ponder the lasting impact of their encounter and the ambiguous nature of their fates.

Director's Vision: Alessio Cremonini's Unflinching Lens

Alessio Cremonini's vision for "Profeti" is to create a gritty, realistic, and profoundly psychological examination of radicalization, trauma, and the human spirit's resilience in extreme captivity.

• Unflinching Realism: True to his style in films like "On My Skin," Cremonini aims for a documentary-like authenticity in portraying the harsh realities of captivity, avoiding dramatization or sensationalism. He focuses on the small details that make the situation feel real and terrifying.

• Psychological Intensity in Confinement: The director deliberately limits the setting to a confined space (Sara's cell), intending to maximize psychological tension and force an intense focus on the intricate power dynamics and emotional shifts between the two lead characters.

• Exploring Radicalization's Roots: Cremonini seeks to understand why individuals like Nur become radicalized, portraying it as a complex response to profound trauma and a search for belonging or purpose, rather than simply evil. He aims for empathy without condoning actions.

• Dialogue as the Driving Force: The film relies heavily on dialogue to reveal character, advance the plot, and explore complex themes of faith, ideology, and human nature under duress. The verbal sparring and intimate conversations between Sara and Nur are central to his vision.

• The Human Cost of War: Beyond the immediate conflict, Cremonini's vision is to highlight the unseen, psychological scars left by war and extremism on both victims and perpetrators, emphasizing the lasting trauma that shapes their lives.

• Performance-Driven Narrative: He places immense trust in his lead actors, particularly Jasmine Trinca and Isabelle Chihaoui, to convey the film's emotional depth and complex character arcs through their performances.

Themes: Echoes of Humanity

• Captivity and Freedom: The physical confinement of Sara juxtaposed with the psychological freedom or imprisonment of both characters' minds.

• Radicalization and Trauma: Exploring how extreme experiences, particularly violence and displacement, can lead individuals to embrace radical ideologies.

• Faith and Ideology: The complex role of belief systems, both as sources of strength and as tools for control and justification of violence.

• The Scars of War: Beyond physical conflict, the film delves into the profound and lasting psychological wounds inflicted by war on individuals.

• Human Connection in Adversity: The unexpected moments of empathy, understanding, or even a twisted form of bond that can develop between captor and captive.

• Survival and Resilience: The indomitable human spirit's fight for survival, both physically and psychologically, in the face of unimaginable terror.

Key Success Factors: Ingredients for Triumph

• Jasmine Trinca's Powerful Performance: Her portrayal of Sara is widely lauded as captivating and emotionally raw, carrying the film's intense psychological weight.

• Intense Two-Hander Dynamic: The compelling and nuanced relationship between Sara and Nur (Isabelle Chihaoui) is the film's engine, driving its tension and thematic exploration.

• Alessio Cremonini's Unflinching Realism: The director's commitment to a gritty, authentic portrayal of captivity elevates the film beyond sensationalism, lending it significant dramatic weight and credibility.

• Claustrophobic Setting: The confined prison cell effectively amplifies the psychological tension and forces an intimate focus on the characters' internal struggles.

• Timely and Relevant Subject Matter: The film tackles complex issues of radicalization, terrorism, and trauma with sensitivity and depth, resonating with contemporary global concerns.

Awards and Nominations: Acknowledged Brilliance

"Profeti" (Prophets) has garnered some notable recognition, particularly in Italy and at festivals:

• Rome Film Fest 2022 (World Premiere): Official Selection

• David di Donatello Awards (2024 - Italy's Oscars):

  • Nomination: Best Actress (Jasmine Trinca)

• Nastri d'Argento Awards (2024 - Italy's Golden Globes):

  • Nomination: Best Actress (Jasmine Trinca)

  • Nomination: Best Screenplay (Alessio Cremonini, Monica Zapelli)

  • Nomination: Best Editing (Marco Spoletini)

While not a major festival circuit juggernaut, these nominations for acting, writing, and editing within Italy's top film awards indicate strong critical recognition for its artistic merit, particularly Trinca's performance.

Critics Reception: Voices from the Critics

Cineuropa (Vittoria Scarpa):

• Summary: Scarpa praises the film as a "dense and complex drama" that delves into the "psychological and ideological mechanisms of radicalisation." She highlights the "gripping duel" between the two actresses, calling Jasmine Trinca's performance "powerful and physically demanding" and Isabelle Chihaoui "magnificent." She notes Cremonini's commitment to "dry realism" and his "courage to venture into little-explored territory," making it a "dramatic tale of freedom, trauma and faith."

• Overall Impression: Highly positive, commending the film's thematic depth, performances, and unflinching realism.

Mymovies.it (Carola Proto):

• Summary: Proto gives the film 3 out of 5 stars. She notes it's a "tightly built film that is all played on the dialogue" between the two women. She praises Cremonini for treating the complex subject "with the necessary respect and sensitivity." However, she also suggests that the film, while powerful, can be "exhausting" due to its relentless focus and intensity, and that the conclusion might leave some questions unanswered.

• Overall Impression: Generally positive, appreciating the film's intensity and sensitive approach, but acknowledging its demanding nature.

Filmitalia:

• Summary: Describes the film as a "dramatic tale of freedom, trauma, and faith" about a Western journalist held by ISIS. It emphasizes the film's focus on the "psychological and ideological mechanisms" of radicalization.

• Overall Impression: Informational, highlighting the film's core themes.

Cinemaitaliano.info (Lorenzo Fantoli):

• Summary: Fantoli praises Cremonini's ability to maintain "a strong realistic imprint" while exploring the complexities of radicalization. He highlights the "great interpretations" of the two leads, especially Jasmine Trinca, and the "chilling portrait" of Nur. He notes the film's strength in portraying the "intense psychological dynamic."

• Overall Impression: Very positive, emphasizing the realism, performances, and psychological depth.

Overall Critics Reception Summary:

"Profeti" has received a resoundingly positive critical reception, particularly within Italy. Critics consistently praise Alessio Cremonini's unflinching commitment to realism and his courageous decision to tackle the sensitive and complex subject of radicalization and captivity with depth and empathy, rather than sensationalism. The film's greatest strength is widely considered to be the powerful and intense two-hander dynamic between Jasmine Trinca and Isabelle Chihaoui, with Trinca's performance frequently highlighted as a standout that effectively carries the film's psychological weight. Reviewers commend the film for its tight narrative structure, compelling dialogue, and ability to generate profound tension within a confined setting. While some note its relentless intensity might be challenging for some viewers, the overall consensus is that "Profeti" is a brave, intelligent, and emotionally resonant drama that offers a crucial and humane look into the unseen scars of war and the complexities of human belief systems.

Reviews

MUBI:

• Summary: Provides a brief synopsis focused on Sara's captivity and Nur's conversion. It lists basic cast and crew information.

• Overall Impression: Informational, not a detailed review.

Cineblog.it (Andrea Mercurio):

• Summary: Mercurio gives the film 3.5 out of 5 stars, describing it as "a powerful drama" that manages to portray a very delicate topic with "great respect and without clichés." He praises the "magnificent acting of Jasmine Trinca and Isabelle Chihaoui" and notes how the director "gives us a film where the main protagonists are the words." He concludes it's a "film that makes you think a lot and that invites reflection on a complex world."

• Overall Impression: Very positive, emphasizing the respectful approach, strong acting, and thought-provoking nature.

il Fatto Quotidiano (Antonello Catacchio):

• Summary: Catacchio writes that "Profeti is a true challenge, to represent a terrible reality like that of ISIS, the kidnapping of Westerners... Cremonini faces the task with courage and intelligence." He highlights the intensity of the "duel" between Trinca and Chihaoui, noting how their conflict is "almost a ballet of gestures and words." He finds the film to be "painful, often harsh, but also very human."

• Overall Impression: Highly positive, commending the film's courage, intelligence, and humanistic approach to a difficult subject.

Overall Reviews Summary:

Reviews for "Profeti" consistently underscore its strength as a performance-driven psychological drama rooted in a harrowing real-world context. The intensity of the two lead actresses, Jasmine Trinca and Isabelle Chihaoui, is universally praised, with many reviewers noting how their "duel of words and wills" carries the film. Critics commend Alessio Cremonini for his realistic and respectful handling of the sensitive subject matter of ISIS captivity and radicalization, avoiding easy answers or sensationalism. The film's confined setting and reliance on dialogue are seen as assets, creating a gripping and immersive experience. While some acknowledge its unrelenting intensity, the overarching sentiment is that "Profeti" is a courageous, intelligent, and deeply human film that effectively explores themes of faith, trauma, and the complexities of survival in extreme circumstances. Its strong reception in Italian film circles further cements its artistic merit.

Box Office: A Modest Arthouse Performance

"Profeti" had its world premiere at the Rome Film Fest in October 2022, but its general theatrical release in Italy occurred in January 2023.

Detailed worldwide box office figures are not widely available on standard aggregators like Box Office Mojo or The Numbers, which is typical for independent, non-English language art-house films with a focused distribution strategy.

Based on Italian sources and its distribution pattern, "Profeti" likely had a modest theatrical run in Italy, appealing to a discerning audience interested in serious dramas and the work of Alessio Cremonini and Jasmine Trinca. Its success would be measured more by critical acclaim, awards nominations (especially within Italy), and long-term streaming/VOD performance rather than large commercial grosses. It performed as expected for a prestige drama of its nature.

Production Summary: An Italian-Belgian Collaboration

"Profeti" is a 2023 Italian drama film with a running time of 86 minutes.

• Directed by: Alessio Cremonini

• Written by: Alessio Cremonini, Monica Zapelli

• Produced by: Lucky Red, Rai Cinema, with Belgium's Ryder Film co-producing.

• Starring:

  • Jasmine Trinca as Sara (the Italian journalist)

  • Isabelle Chihaoui as Nur (the Syrian convert/jailer)

• Cinematography: Gianluca Signaroli

• Edited by: Marco Spoletini (nominated for Nastri d'Argento)

• Music by: not widely specified, focusing on ambient sound and psychological tension.

• Production Companies: Lucky Red, Rai Cinema, Ryder Film (Belgium)

• Distributed by: Lucky Red (Italy)

• Country of Origin: Italy (Co-produced with Belgium)

• Language: Italian, Arabic (with subtitles)

• MPA Rating: Not widely specified for US, likely a mature rating (e.g., R for themes of violence, trauma, and mature content).

The production involved extensive research into the realities of captivity and radicalization, aiming for authenticity in its portrayal of the confined environment and the psychological dynamic between the characters.

Release Dates: From Festival Premiere to Italian Screens

• World Premiere: October 20, 2022 (Rome Film Fest)

• Italian Theatrical Release: January 26, 2023

• Other International Releases: Varied throughout 2023 and 2024, typically through film festivals or limited art-house distribution in specific territories.

Why to Recommend Movie: A Cinematic Invitation

• For Lovers of Intense Character Studies: If you appreciate films that delve deeply into complex human relationships and psychological dynamics in extreme situations.

• Powerful Acting Showcase: A must-see for anyone who wants to witness a truly commanding and emotionally resonant lead performance by Jasmine Trinca.

• Insightful Look at Radicalization: If you're interested in exploring the human and psychological roots of extremism, rather than simplistic portrayals.

• Alessio Cremonini's Signature Realism: For fans of the director's unflinching and authentic approach to difficult contemporary subjects.

• Timely and Thought-Provoking: It's a film that bravely tackles a sensitive and relevant global issue, sparking important conversations.

Why to Watch Movie: The Power of Presence

• Experience Unrelenting Tension: The confined setting and intense dialogue create a gripping, high-stakes atmosphere.

• Witness a Powerful Two-Hander: The dynamic between Sara and Nur is the heart of the film, offering a masterclass in screen acting.

• Challenge Your Perspectives: The film will invite you to consider the complexities of faith, trauma, and humanity in conflict zones.

• Appreciate Artistic Restraint: See how a director can achieve profound impact through focused storytelling and a lack of sensationalism.

• Discover Acclaimed Italian Cinema: Explore a critically praised film from one of Europe's vibrant national cinemas.

Movie Trend: Following the Current

"Profeti" aligns strongly with the trend of "Realist Psychological Dramas" that tackle difficult, often geopolitical, subjects through intimate, character-driven narratives, frequently set in confined spaces. It also contributes to the ongoing focus in cinema on "Post-Conflict Trauma and Radicalization," seeking to understand the human toll and underlying causes of extremism rather than merely depicting its violence. Furthermore, it exemplifies the continued strength of "Italian Auteur Cinema" in creating impactful and socially relevant films for a global audience, often with a focus on powerful central performances.

Social Trend: Mirroring Society

"Profeti" acutely mirrors the pervasive social trend of global anxieties surrounding extremism, radicalization, and the psychological impact of prolonged conflict and captivity. In a world increasingly grappling with the aftermath of conflicts in regions like the Middle East and the complex issue of returning foreign fighters or radicalized individuals, the film offers a crucial human perspective. It specifically addresses the trend of seeking to understand the human stories behind radicalization, moving beyond simplistic portrayals of "evil" to explore trauma, desperation, and the search for belonging or purpose as potential pathways to extremist ideologies. The film also reflects a broader societal concern with the fate of war correspondents and humanitarians in conflict zones, highlighting the extreme dangers they face and the lasting psychological scars they endure. It encourages a more nuanced and empathetic understanding of complex geopolitical issues through individual human narratives.

Final Verdict: A Gripping and Unflinching Look at Faith, Fear, and Survival

"Profeti" is a powerful, raw, and deeply unsettling psychological drama that confronts the harrowing realities of extremism and captivity with remarkable sensitivity and unflinching realism. Alessio Cremonini's direction is taut and purposeful, creating an intensely claustrophobic atmosphere within the confined setting that amplifies the psychological tension. The film's greatest strength lies in the extraordinary performances of Jasmine Trinca and Isabelle Chihaoui, whose gripping two-hander dynamic is both intellectually stimulating and emotionally devastating. Trinca's portrayal of resilience and subtle resistance is compelling, while Chihaoui embodies the chilling complexities of a traumatized individual turned radicalized jailer. "Profeti" bravely delves into the thorny questions of faith, trauma, and the human capacity for both cruelty and unexpected connection in the face of unspeakable terror. While its relentless intensity demands full engagement, this critically acclaimed Italian production offers a vital, humane, and timely exploration of an often-misunderstood facet of modern conflict, leaving a profound and lasting impact.

Recommendations for Filmmakers: Building Intense Drama from Confined Realities

• Master the Power of the Confined Setting: Embrace limited locations to maximize psychological tension and character interaction. "Profeti" demonstrates how a single, stark room can become a vibrant arena for a battle of wills, forcing a deep exploration of character and theme through dialogue and subtle physical cues.

• Invest in Performance-Driven Narratives: Build your film around the strength of your actors. When tackling sensitive or challenging subjects, truly exceptional performances, like those in "Profeti," can humanize complex issues and carry the entire emotional weight of the story, making the audience connect deeply.

• Approach Sensitive Subjects with Nuance and Respect: When dealing with topics like radicalization or war trauma, strive for authenticity and avoid sensationalism or simplistic villainization. "Profeti" shows how empathy, even for complex antagonists, can lead to a more profound and thought-provoking exploration of difficult realities.

• Prioritize Psychological Realism Over Overt Action: Focus on the internal struggles and emotional landscapes of your characters. The film proves that intense drama and suspense can be generated through psychological manipulation, moral dilemmas, and the gradual unraveling of a character's composure, rather than relying on external events.

Recommendations for Movie Industry: Backing Bold Stories and Uncomfortable Truths

• Champion Authentic, Unflinching Dramas: Actively seek out and support films that are unafraid to confront difficult, timely, and often uncomfortable social or geopolitical realities with realism and depth. These films, while not always mass-market, are crucial for fostering understanding and critical discourse.

• Invest in Diverse International Voices and Perspectives: Recognize the value of non-English language cinema in offering unique cultural insights and challenging Western-centric narratives. "Profeti" highlights the power of Italian cinema to contribute significantly to global conversations on complex issues.

• Support Films with Strong, Character-Focused Concepts: Beyond high-concept premises, prioritize projects that promise a deep dive into human psychology and relationships, particularly in extreme circumstances. Powerful character studies often resonate deeply with audiences and critics.

• Utilize Festival Recognition to Build Momentum: Leverage premieres and awards at prestigious film festivals (like Rome Film Fest and David di Donatello nominations for "Profeti") as key marketing tools to attract niche audiences and critical attention, ensuring these important films find their deserved audience.

Final Conclusions: "Profeti": A Crucial Dialogue on Faith, Freedom, and the Enduring Echoes of Conflict

"Profeti" is an unflinching, vital, and profoundly human drama that courageously plunges into the dark heart of extremism and the psychological crucible of captivity. Alessio Cremonini’s masterful direction, characterized by its stark realism and intense focus, creates a suffocating yet compelling environment that mirrors the internal struggles of its characters. The film is elevated by the magnificent and visceral performances of Jasmine Trinca and Isabelle Chihaoui, who create an unforgettable dynamic of terror, manipulation, and fragile understanding. Through their confined dialogue, the film not only illuminates the terrifying mechanisms of radicalization but also delves into the universal human quest for meaning and freedom in the face of unimaginable despair. "Profeti" is far more than a simple hostage thriller; it is a thought-provoking and deeply empathetic exploration of the unseen scars left by war and the complex interplay of faith and trauma. This powerful Italian film serves as a poignant reminder of the enduring human spirit and the crucial need to understand the profound, often hidden, realities of global conflict.