Movies: We Forgot to Break Up (2024) by Karen Knox: A raw, nostalgic, and queer-infused ode to the messy beauty of youth, love, and indie rock dreams
- dailyentertainment95
- Oct 17
- 5 min read
The sound of youth, rebellion, and self-discovery
We Forgot to Break Up (2024) is a Canadian coming-of-age music drama directed by Karen Knox and written by Noel S. Baker, Pat Mills, and Zoë Whittall.
Set in the late 1990s and early 2000s, the film follows The New Normals, a scrappy band of misfits from a small Ontario town who escape to Toronto chasing fame, freedom, and a shot at musical immortality. As they find their voice in the city’s underground indie scene, fame brings creative tension, romantic chaos, and a deep exploration of gender and identity that threatens to tear the group apart — unless they can rediscover what first made them a band.
Loosely adapted from Whittall’s acclaimed novel and short film, We Forgot to Break Up captures the heartbeat of a generation raised on punk ethics and queer love — a bittersweet portrait of what it means to outgrow your past without losing your people.
Why to Recommend: For anyone who ever loved a song that saved them
A love letter to Canadian indie rock: The film evokes the sound and spirit of early-2000s Toronto, where basement bars and bedroom demos defined a scene.
Authentic queer storytelling: Nonbinary and trans identities are portrayed with honesty and heart, not as side notes but as central to the band’s creative energy.
Dynamic ensemble cast: Lane Webber, Daniel Gravelle, and June Laporte deliver lived-in performances that pulse with chaotic chemistry.
Raw, DIY aesthetic: Knox mirrors the grainy authenticity of early digital video, turning nostalgia into visual poetry.
Summary: We Forgot to Break Up is about friendship, failure, and finding yourself in the noise — a film that plays like a mixtape of heartbreak and hope.
Where to watch: https://www.justwatch.com/us/movie/we-forgot-to-break-up-2024 (US), https://www.justwatch.com/au/movie/we-forgot-to-break-up-2024 (Australia), https://www.justwatch.com/ca/movie/we-forgot-to-break-up-2024 (Canada), https://www.justwatch.com/uk/movie/we-forgot-to-break-up-2024 (UK), https://www.justwatch.com/fr/film/nous-avons-oublie-de-rompre (France)
Link IMDB: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt3576752/
About movie: https://www.tiff.net/events/we-forgot-to-break-up
What is the Trend Followed: Queer indie realism and nostalgic musical cinema
The film rides a wave of queer-centered, music-driven narratives that mix raw realism with creative catharsis.
Post-punk nostalgia: Echoes the tone of Hedwig and the Angry Inch and We Are the Best! — music as rebellion and identity.
Found-family storytelling: Reflects the trend toward stories about chosen families over traditional ones.
Mockumentary texture: Blends vérité camerawork and archival-style footage to heighten realism.
Gender fluidity on screen: Part of a growing canon of Canadian films embracing nonbinary and trans characters with authenticity (Something You Said Last Night, Solo).
Music as memory: Uses the indie soundtrack not as background but as emotional narration — each track marking a milestone in the characters’ evolution.
Summary: The film reflects the era’s creative restlessness — the messy intersection of queerness, youth, and art in transition.
Director’s Vision: Chaos as connection
Karen Knox, known for Slo Pitch and Adult Adoption, brings her signature blend of humor, heartbreak, and queer tenderness to this debut feature.
Emotional verité: Knox’s direction feels intimate and unpolished, capturing fleeting moments of youth with documentary-like realism.
Collaborative energy: The cast lived together before shooting to recreate the “band house” chaos and chemistry.
Cinematic texture: Handheld shots, lens flares, and DIY lighting evoke a 2000s VHS feel that blurs fiction and memory.
Performance-centered storytelling: The director allows improvisation, letting the actors inhabit their band’s dynamics authentically.
Musical realism: The film’s soundtrack features both original songs written by the cast and era-defining Canadian indie tracks curated by the music supervisor.
Summary: Knox turns a chaotic band story into a cinematic jam session — imperfect, passionate, and deeply alive.
Themes: Identity, friendship, and the art of falling apart gracefully
Chosen family: How creative communities become homes for the misfits.
Gender and transformation: Fluid identities intersect with art, desire, and reinvention.
Youth and nostalgia: Growing up means realizing that not every bond survives the dream.
Fame and authenticity: The tension between staying true to yourself and “selling out.”
Love as art: Relationships as creative acts — beautiful, destructive, and fleeting.
Summary: The film captures the duality of youth — wild freedom and quiet heartbreak — reminding us that creation often means destruction.
Key Success Factors: Chemistry, soundtrack, and sincerity
Performances: The ensemble’s natural chemistry drives the film’s emotional core.
Soundtrack: A mix of original songs and Canadian indie deep cuts builds a lived-in musical universe.
Tone: A perfect blend of humor, melancholy, and rebellion.
Representation: Trans and queer stories integrated naturally into the narrative, without tokenism.
Festival appeal: Authentic, youth-driven storytelling makes it a crowd favorite in indie circuits.
Summary: What the film lacks in polish, it makes up for in authenticity — it feels like a garage band in love with its own chaos.
Critical Reception: Warm, niche, and emotionally resonant
Canadian Film Review: “A raw, joyful portrait of queer youth and music culture — noisy, tender, and impossible to forget.”
The Globe and Mail: “Karen Knox captures the aching sweetness of impermanence — a coming-of-age film that hums with heart.”
IndieWire: “Part mockumentary, part love letter — We Forgot to Break Up is messy, funny, and full of feeling.”
Audience consensus: Emotional resonance outweighs narrative roughness — a film that feels true.
Summary: Critics highlight its heart and humor, noting that We Forgot to Break Up succeeds not through perfection, but through honesty.
Audience Appeal: For the dreamers, lovers, and lost kids of the 2000s
For fans of: Almost Famous, Hedwig and the Angry Inch, Sing Street, We Are the Best!
Tone: Warm, wistful, and rhythmically chaotic.
Viewer experience: Feels like flipping through a friend’s old tour diary — intimate, scrappy, and full of emotion.
Resonance: Speaks to anyone who’s ever been young, broke, queer, and chasing art.
Consensus: “A queer rock elegy to youth — chaotic, honest, and beautifully human.”
Industry Trend: The revival of queer indie cinema
We Forgot to Break Up stands among a new wave of Canadian and global queer films that blend punk sensibility with emotional storytelling. It reflects an industry shift toward authentic representation, where queer lives aren’t defined by trauma but by creation, community, and imperfection.
Cultural Trend: Music as memory, identity as evolution
The film resonates with a generation raised between analog rebellion and digital change. By using music as both emotional expression and social commentary, it captures the early 2000s ethos — when art was identity and love was rebellion.
Final Verdict: Loud, messy, and unforgettable
We Forgot to Break Up (2024) is a raucous, heartfelt celebration of queer friendship and youthful ambition — a film that hums with energy, longing, and life. Karen Knox conducts her cast like a punk orchestra, crafting a story that feels spontaneous yet deeply sincere.Verdict: A love song to growing up, breaking down, and making noise — vulnerable, defiant, and beautifully human.
Comments